Career & Work

Severance's Non-Disparagement Clause vs Your Right to Report

Your severance check can't buy your right to call a regulator. Here is where these clauses hold and what to strike.

Largern Staff

Largern Staff

Largern Desk

Nov 7, 20267 min read
Severance's Non-Disparagement Clause vs Your Right to Report

On March 3, 2026, a National Labor Relations Board administrative law judge named Robert A. Giannasi ruled that Valley Radiology had violated federal labor law. The company had not fired anyone for organizing, cut pay or threatened a union campaign. It had handed over a severance agreement, and the breadth of that document was the violation.

A Clause That Broke Labor Law on Its Own Merits

The ruling rests on McLaren Macomb, 372 NLRB No. 58, decided in February 2023, which reset severance drafting for private employers of every size. The Board held that offering an agreement with overbroad non-disparagement or confidentiality provisions violates Section 8(a)(1), because those terms have a reasonable tendency to restrain employees from discussing working conditions or filing charges. Coverage extended to non-union workplaces, which is why the decision reached hospitals, logistics operators and software firms alike.

The clause that drew fire was not written by a villain. The agreement in McLaren Macomb contained this line: "At all times hereafter, the Employee agrees not to make statements to Employer's employees or to the general public which could disparage or harm the image of Employer, its parent and affiliated entities and their officers, directors, employees, agents and representatives." Read strictly, it covers a complaint to a federal agency and a truthful account to a colleague. Employees weighing a check against an open-ended gag usually choose the check.

Narrower drafting survives. Guidance issued alongside the decision accepted that limited confidentiality and non-disparagement language can be lawful, that a boilerplate disclaimer is not a reliable fix and that the standard reaches agreements already signed. The line between lawful and unlawful is whether the departing employee keeps a clean path to the NLRB, the EEOC, the SEC and any other regulator with jurisdiction over the employer.

The Prosecutors Left. The Precedent Stayed.

Enforcement appetite changed fast. On February 14, 2025, Acting General Counsel William B. Cowen issued Memorandum GC 25-05, rescinding more than 30 memos from his predecessor, including the 2023 guidance on how aggressively the agency would pursue severance clauses. Regional offices lost their roadmap, and employers read the move as permission to restore older templates.

A general counsel memo is not the law. It tells field offices what to prosecute, and its withdrawal leaves Board precedent standing. Administrative law judges keep applying McLaren Macomb when a charge reaches their docket, which produced the Valley Radiology ruling 13 months after the memo was pulled. Former employees and unions can file those charges without any encouragement from Washington.

The result is a two-tier market in severance paperwork. Employees at companies with sophisticated employment counsel get agreements carrying regulator carve-outs. Employees at firms working from a five-year-old template get the broad version and a 21-day signature window, with the odds of any test resting on who signs and whether anyone with standing decides to file.

Two Agencies, Two Very Different Price Tags

Two regulators matter more than the rest, and they price the same clause in different currencies.

ForumGoverning ruleWhat triggers liabilityTypical exposure
NLRBNLRA Sections 7 and 8(a)(1), plus McLaren Macomb (2023)Offering an overbroad clause, even with no retaliationRescission of the clause and cease-and-desist orders, no civil fine
SECRule 21F-17(a) under Dodd-FrankAny action impeding contact with SEC staff, including a signed releaseMonetary settlements from six figures upward
IllinoisWorkplace Transparency Act, amended by HB 3638 effective January 1, 2026Agreements lacking required carve-outs or documented employee preferenceExpanded private remedies, voided terms
CaliforniaState limits on settlement confidentiality in harassment and discrimination casesConfidentiality terms covering protected conductUnenforceable terms and litigation risk
United KingdomEmployment Rights Act 2025 plus the 2026 consultationNDAs that stop workers disclosing harassment or discriminationVoid terms except in approved agreements

The SEC does not need a retaliation victim. Rule 21F-17(a) bars any action that impedes an individual from communicating directly with Commission staff about a possible securities violation, and the agency has treated contract language as the action. Its enforcement record shows 11 actions in fiscal 2025 involving agreements or conduct that chilled whistleblower communications, more than double the five brought in fiscal 2023. One carried an $18 million penalty.

What separates the two regimes is what each agency must prove. The NLRB argues about drafting and tendency. The SEC points to a signed document whose terms could deter a call. Individual settlements have run from $225,000 to the eight-figure outlier, and one batch of separation and confidentiality agreement cases produced fines above $3 million in aggregate.

What the Check Actually Buys

Set a $120,000 salary against the common benchmark of two weeks per year of service. That salary is $2,308 a week, so an employee with six years of tenure collects $27,700 before tax, plus accrued leave. That is the entire consideration for signing. The clause attached to it can run for years and reach statements the employee has not yet made.

Price the other side. Dodd-Frank whistleblower awards run between 10% and 30% of monetary sanctions above $1 million in a covered action. A $10 million sanction pays at least $1 million at the floor of that range, roughly 36 times the severance above. Even a $1 million sanction yields $100,000, still more than three times the check.

That math only bites for employees holding information a regulator wants, which is a small group. The quieter cost is ambiguity. A clause naming no carve-outs leaves open whether a call to a regulator breaches a contract, and that question is enough to produce delay and eventual silence. Five lines decide whether the packet is boilerplate or a trap:

  • A named carve-out for the NLRB, EEOC, SEC, OSHA and any other agency with jurisdiction over the employer.
  • Explicit permission to testify truthfully and cooperate with government investigations.
  • A confidentiality definition that excludes wages, working conditions and conduct the employee reasonably believes is unlawful.
  • No liquidated damages, clawback or fee-shifting triggered by a disparagement claim.
  • One sentence stating that nothing in the agreement limits eligibility for a whistleblower award.

The Patchwork Is Rewriting the Standard Form

State law is moving faster than the federal agency. Illinois House Bill 3638, signed on August 15, 2025 and effective January 1, 2026, amended the Workplace Transparency Act to broaden the definition of unlawful employment practices, protect concerted activity and expand remedies. Agreements now need clear carve-outs for truthful disclosures or documented evidence of the employee's preference for confidentiality.

Britain is heading the same way with more procedure attached. The Employment Rights Act 2025 will void non-disclosure terms that stop workers speaking about harassment or discrimination, and a consultation opened in April 2026 on how exceptions should work. Draft requirements include independent legal advice, written and informed consent and a cooling-off period before an agreement binds, with disclosures to regulators kept outside the restricted zone.

The divergence matters for anyone negotiating with a multinational, because one global template no longer survives contact with local law. Employees in stricter jurisdictions get carve-outs by default, and colleagues elsewhere can cite the same corporate policy as precedent. For the small share of workers with real leverage, exit terms are drifting into the compensation conversation, much as leadership searches for scarce AI talent have folded disclosure questions into the offer itself.

The severance agreement is a contract about the past that gets priced in the present, and employers buy silence at a discount because most silence is never tested. The agencies that would test it are working with thinner guidance than they had three years ago, and the precedent that remains is enforced mostly by whoever bothers to file. A carve-out protecting the right to call a regulator usually costs an employer nothing, which is the strongest reason to read the clause twice before the pen comes out.

Strategic Takeaways

  • ✓Severance paperwork can itself violate federal labor law when its non-disparagement and confidentiality language reaches an employee's right to complain or file charges.
  • ✓The NLRB's general counsel stopped pursuing those cases in February 2025, yet the underlying precedent still binds administrative law judges and still produces rulings.
  • ✓The SEC's whistleblower rule carries the heavier price tag because it penalizes the clause in the contract rather than requiring proof of retaliation.
Largern Staff
About the Author

Largern Staff

Collaborative ideas and essays from the Largern desk on the ideas, habits, and shifts shaping modern life.

Comments (0)

Join the Discussion

No comments yet

Be the first reader to share your perspective on this story.

Related Coverage